We've another new restaurant that just opened earlier this month in the Columbia Heights neighborhood. It's an intriguing place with an upscale British-American fusion concept called CommonWealth GastroPub. Having eaten at many a British pub during my college student days at Oxford, I recognized many of the more "unusual" items on the menu, yet I had to shudder at the very un-pub-like high prices.
The food, though, turned out to be very good, and the service was fun, so, I'm sure we'll end up back at this place (after I get another bank loan) to try out some of the other items on the menu.
On this our first visit, my neighbor Joel and I decided to sit out on the patio. This turned out to be an iffy choice, as we would get rained on by the time we were eating our desserts, but, hey, it's a British place, and it rains a lot in England.
Mike, a GWU student, was our waiter, and Joel kept him running and pumped him for information, and Mike expertly was up to the challenge. He recommended foods on the menu and was a font of information about the very extensive beer and ale list.
During the midst of all Joel's questioning, I nibbled on some complimentary relishes the waiter brought, being pickled green beans, beets, cauliflower, and something we think was yellow squash.
Joel decided he was going to get the chocolate stout ice cream float for dessert (which he didn't end up doing....more on that later), so he got a bottle of the double chocolate stout to drink. He reported that it didn't really have a chocolate flavor, though it had an unusual complexity for beer. Joel also insisted that I have a cocktail, so I got "The Churchill," their own blend of Tanqueray Rangpur gin (Tanq's special blend with the additional tastes of lime, bay leaf, and ginger), limoncello (a lemon liqueur), and grapefruit juice garnished with orange (I forget what was in it that gave it the blush-red color). It wasn't really my favorite. It just sort of screamed CITRUS!!! and it wasn't good citrus, it was pithy citrus (think the bitter white part under the skin). Anyway, after downing my drink, I switched to my usual iced tea. Later, though, Joel would get another beer, a lager called St. Pete's that the waiter said was one of his favorites, and that came in a really interesting green, oval bottle.
But, enough about alcohol. Let's talk about the food.
Joel started with the crab-on-toast. It was delicious. It was a good quantity of crab meat with just a touch of white sauce to bind it together piled up on a piece of toasted bread, and had a nice, rich flavor. Staying in a similar vein, I got their Welsh rarebit—sometimes also called Welsh "rabbit." Now, rarebit is usually leftover cheese rinds melted in beer and served over toast, but they had to be more upscale about it. So, we got two types of distinct cheese melted in a stout brown beer that was ladled over toast and broiled. It was very good, though I'm not used to the dark brown color (from the stout) on my melted cheese.
SInce he'd been talking about the fish and chips since before the place even opened, that's what Joel ordered for his main course. The fish was beer-battered, though he reported there wasn't any beer flavor. In fact, he thought his fish reminded him of a funnel cake! Malt vinegar, though, helped provide needed richness to the fried fish. Along with the fish came "chips," or some really, really thick-cut French fries. I tried a couple and I think they were so big, they weren't able to be completely cooked through. As a supplemental side dish, he got a cauliflower gratin, very traditionally done in a bechamel sauce. This being Friday, I also got fish, selecting the "simply grilled fish with parsley sauce," and today's fish being a lovely bluefish served atop a bed of puréed cauliflower. A big wad of watercress topped the fish. It was a nice dish, the fish being grilled to the correct degree of doneness and having a nice, seasoned, grill flavor.
I really hadn't planned on doing dessert, but we decided to do it anyway just to try out more menu items. Joel got the lemon trifle, originally slated to be layered with raspberry sauce, but tonight being made with a lingonberry/blueberry mix. The trifle had been assembled in the serving container with alternating layers of lemon pudding, berries, and cake. I got the warm treacle tart, something best described as a little pecan pie made with molasses instead of corn syrup and without the pecans.
About this time, it started to rain. Most of us out on the patio moved into the main dining room and bar, but those places were packed, and there wasn't really any place to stand or sit. Meanwhile, we observed the unusual grey monochrome decor on the inside, and Joel noted that the entry was designed to be reminiscent of those old red British phone booths. Eventually, we finished our drinks, paid our check, and headed home.
I expect, though, that we'll be back.